Lehi man ordered to rip out his new xeriscape landscaping by his HOA

Approximated examine time: 4-5 minutes

LEHI — As he was creating a new property in Lehi, Jared Hadley was eager to heed the phone calls to set in landscaping that uses very little or no water.

“We noticed it as an prospect to be like, hey, we could seriously make a distinction in the setting,” he stated.

Hadley mounted landscaping consisting of a couple h2o-smart crops surrounded by river rocks and attractive gravel. “It appears lovely,” he explained.

It’s the kind of landscaping that has the hearty assistance of all people from drinking water experts and Utah politicos.

But you know who won’t like it? Hadley’s homeowner’s association.

An e-mail from his HOA, Holbrook Farms, states that he is most likely likely to have to tear out the gravel components to put in some thing of which they approve like “mulch, river rock, or sod.”

Hadley says he protested, pointing out that gravel is the improved choice.

“You will find not substances like mulch. It can be not sod, wherever we are acquiring to water it,” he said.

By e mail, an HOA agent advised Hadley ought to have submitted an application and web page strategy right before executing the work. He was instructed to submit the files for the currently concluded perform but admonished that if the HOA does not signal off, and the representative is “confident” they will not, Hadley will have to repair it to their liking or encounter fines.

And indeed, Thursday, Hadley obtained word that his landscaping is not authorized and he is currently being ordered to change it. “It just, it is really mind-boggling,” he said.

An HOA ruling with an iron fist on what an exterior can glance like is not unique. In actuality, the KSL Investigators have read from more than a dozen men and women who are living in different HOA’s in Utah stating they want to put in xeriscaping or artificial grass to preserve water but are remaining rebuffed by their associations.

The problem is: Can they do that?

Here in Utah there is a new law, HB282, which says municipalities and HOA’s can’t have procedures that prohibit water-sensible landscaping.

Sen. Mike McKell, who co-sponsored the new legislation, states the bill was motivated by Utah’s dire drinking water predicament as well as predictable drinking water concerns for many years to come.

“We are in a drought,” McKell told the KSL Investigators. “We are also in a state that is growing at a level which is just not sustainable without earning improvements across the point out.”

Jared Hadley was eager to heed the calls to put in landscaping that uses little or no water. His HOA opposed his work.
Jared Hadley was keen to heed the phone calls to set in landscaping that works by using tiny or no drinking water. His HOA opposed his function. (Image: Josh Syzmanik, KSL-Tv)

McKell states he thinks the monthly bill struck an crucial equilibrium of necessitating governing administration companies and associations to allow for persons who want to conserve the authorized protection to do so without the need of banning cities and associations from generating certain their communities maintain their aesthetics.

He states the place of the legislation is to “make sure that if somebody’s received a fantastic program that features xeriscaping, let’s make absolutely sure that they can do that.”

Back again to Hadley, can Holbrook Farms pressure him to remove the h2o-wise-gravel or other xeriscaping he currently put in? The association certainly thinks so.

Holbrook Farms refused to talk about any of this on digital camera and refused to discuss Hadley’s problem at all.

When questioned if they imagine their landscaping guidelines are in line with existing Utah law, Holbrook Farms’ neighborhood supervisor Amanda Howell responded by electronic mail expressing, “certainly.”

“Holbrook Farms has actively implemented drinking water-sensible landscaping strategies into our community’s covenants, situations and polices for the last five years,” Howell mentioned in an e mail. “All house owners will have to comply with our current website plan assessment process prior to making any exterior modifications to their home.”

HB282 spells out that HOAs may possibly pressure house owners to comply with internet site program submission and critique procedures.

According to the HOA’s rules, most landscaping substance that makes use of zero h2o is forbidden from being “considerably” applied, like concrete, masonry items, pavers, brick, stone, cobblestone, tile, terrazzo, slabs, slate, rock, pebbles, gravel, wooden, woodchips, bark, decking and synthetic turf.

Holbrook Farms despatched the KSL Investigators a duplicate of a brochure they gave to Hadley. It depicts water-clever landscape strategies that are authorised. Most of the pictures in the brochure element grass and other plants, all of which, Hadley factors out, have to have more drinking water than the decorative gravel he’s very likely likely to be forced to get rid of.

Questioned if he’d do just about anything differently if he experienced to do it above once more, he explained, “I would not order a residence via an HOA.”

Matt Gephardt

Matt Gephardt has labored in television information for extra than 20 years, and as a reporter since 2010. He is now a customer investigative reporter for KSL Television. You can come across Matt on Twitter at @KSLmatt or e-mail him at [email protected]

Cindy St. Clair

Extra tales you could be fascinated in